Recently, I bought L'oreal Voluminous carbon black and Voluminous water proof.
I have heard a lot about the Voluminous carbon black and decided to try it myself ;)
Voluminous carbon black
It work, it really make your lash thicker and more visible. However its not water proof. As you gals know, i got smudging problems with water proof ones, so this will be problematic for me. I only use it when i know i'm going to have a short day, so i won't be a panda before i got home. Oh ya, one more problem with it, it also clump my lashes.
Voluminous water proof
The original was really popular, but the waterproof one wasn't that popular (i think). But i personally really like it. Its water proof so it smudge less, it really make your lash thicker and more visible. It work better than the Voluminous carbon black and it also does not clump the lashes as much as carbon black.
A friend of my has the original voluminous one and i tried hers before, it was really good. But i only tried once and did not compare the 2 side by side so i'm not sure if its really better than the water proof one. But i do remember that the original one smudge in less than half a day.. LOL..